Framegolf Journal

Golf Basics

Scramble, Best Ball and Other Golf Formats for Groups

A scramble suits a mixed group, and best ball suits golfers who each carry a Handicap Index. The USGA recommends 25%, 20%, 15% and 10% of Course Handicap for a four-person scramble team, lowest handicap first, and 85% for best ball in stroke play.

Which format fits your group

For a group with mixed ability or a few beginners, play a scramble: everyone hits, the team plays its best shot, and one team score goes on the card for each hole. If every player carries a Handicap Index and wants their own ball to count, play best ball, which the Rules of Golf call four-ball: partners each play their own ball and the side takes the lower score on each hole.

Two other formats cover most of what is left. Alternate shot, which the Rules call foursomes, has two partners share one ball, so it needs the fewest swings of any team game. Stableford scores points against par and stops a bad hole at zero, which lets a mixed foursome play as individuals without anyone playing out a ten.

Handicaps make any of them fair. The USGA's Rules of Handicapping publish a recommended allowance for each format in Appendix C. An allowance is the share of a player's Course Handicap, the strokes their Handicap Index converts to on the tees being played, that the player receives in a given format. The committee in charge makes the final call, which for an outing means whoever organizes it, and the allowance should be announced before anyone tees off.

Formats, allowances and whether the score posts

The recommended allowances below come from the USGA's Appendix C table and the Southern California Golf Association's tournament guidance. The SCGA is the USGA's regional association for Southern California, and its guidance spells out how to round. The last column says whether a round in that format can be posted toward a Handicap Index in the United States.

The rule for posting is simple. SCGA puts it in terms of the ball: if you did not play your own ball for the whole round, as in a scramble, a shamble or alternate shot, the score is not posted. Stroke play, Stableford, match play and best ball all post, and in best ball a player who picks up on a hole records their most likely score for it.

Recommended allowances from the USGA Rules of Handicapping, Appendix C, and SCGA guidance dated April 25, 2024. Posting follows SCGA's guidance.
FormatHow it is playedRecommended allowancePosts to a Handicap Index
Individual stroke playEveryone plays their own ball and counts every stroke95% of Course Handicap, or 100% in a field under 30Yes
StablefordPoints per hole against a fixed score, usually par; most points wins95%Yes
Individual match playOne against one, hole by hole100%, with the lowest handicap playing off zeroYes
Best ball (four-ball)Partners each play their own ball; the lower score counts85% in stroke play, 90% in match playYes, with a most likely score for any hole picked up
Scramble, four playersEveryone hits, the team picks the best shot, and all play from there25%, 20%, 15% and 10%, lowest handicap firstNo
Scramble, three playersSame method with a team of three30%, 20% and 10%, lowest handicap firstNo
Scramble, two playersSame method with a team of two35% of the lower handicap plus 15% of the higherNo
Alternate shot (foursomes)Partners share one ball and take turns50% of the partners' combined Course HandicapsNo
Pinehurst (Chapman)Both drive, swap balls for the second shot, keep one ball, then alternate60% of the lower handicap plus 40% of the higherNo

Scramble: how it works and how to split the handicap

SCGA describes the scramble this way: each player tees off, the team chooses the best drive, and every player hits the next shot from that spot, repeating until the ball is holed. A committee can add rules, and the usual one is a minimum number of drives from each player: SCGA suggests three per player in a four-person scramble and six per player in a two-person scramble, and it suggests balancing teams so their handicaps are similar.

For the handicap, Appendix C ranks the team by Course Handicap and gives the largest share to the lowest: 25% for the A player, 20% for B, 15% for C and 10% for D. Three-player teams use 30%, 20% and 10%, a row added in the 2024 revision of the Rules of Handicapping, and two-player teams use 35% of the lower Course Handicap plus 15% of the higher. SCGA rounds each player's figure to a whole number and adds them, and the USGA takes that team handicap off the team's total gross score.

The split looks backwards until you think about whose shots a scramble team plays. The low handicapper's drives and approaches tend to be chosen most often, so that player's ability sets most of the team score, while the high handicapper's shots are used least. If you see the split printed the other way round, with 25% for the highest handicap, it is not the USGA's recommendation, and it hands the team extra strokes.

Take a four-person team with Course Handicaps of 4, 12, 19 and 28. The A player's 25% of 4 is 1.0 stroke and the D player's 10% of 28 is 2.8, and with B and C the rounded shares add up to a team handicap of 9. If that team shoots 64, its net score is 55. Hand out the split in reverse and the same four get 13 strokes.

Shares are 25%, 20%, 15% and 10% for four players, 30%, 20% and 10% for three, and 35% and 15% for two, lowest Course Handicap first. The reversed row gives 25% to the highest handicap instead.
TeamCourse HandicapsShares before roundingTeam handicap
Four players4, 12, 19 and 281.0 + 2.4 + 2.85 + 2.81 + 2 + 3 + 3 = 9
Four players, split reversed4, 12, 19 and 280.4 + 1.8 + 3.8 + 7.00 + 2 + 4 + 7 = 13
Three players6, 15 and 271.8 + 3.0 + 2.72 + 3 + 3 = 8
Two players9 and 213.15 + 3.153 + 3 = 6

Best ball, which the Rules call four-ball

Rule 23 of the Rules of Golf, written jointly by the USGA and The R&A, covers four-ball. Partners compete as a side, each plays a separate ball, and the side's score for a hole is the lower of the partners' scores. When one partner holes out, the other does not have to, which is what keeps best ball moving. In stroke play at least one partner must finish each hole, and a side with no finished score on a hole is disqualified unless the mistake is corrected in time.

The allowance is 85% of Course Handicap in stroke play and 90% in match play. SCGA notes that the stroke play figure used to be 90% for men and 95% for women, and became 85% for all players under the World Handicap System. In match play, apply the 90% first; then the player with the lowest Playing Handicap plays off zero and everyone else receives the difference.

Strokes fall on the holes ranked hardest on the scorecard, stroke index 1 first. A player with a Playing Handicap of 9 gets one stroke on each hole with stroke index 1 to 9, and a player on 20 gets one stroke on every hole plus a second on stroke index 1 and 2.

Best ball still counts toward a Handicap Index, because each player plays their own ball. SCGA's advice for a hole you pick up once your partner has the better score is to post your most likely score for it.

Four-ball match play: the lowest Playing Handicap plays off zero and the others receive the difference. In stroke play the same four play off 85%: 5, 11, 15 and 23.
PlayerCourse HandicapAt 90%Playing HandicapStrokes received
Player 165.450
Player 21311.7127
Player 31816.21611
Player 42724.32419

Alternate shot and Pinehurst: one ball between two

In foursomes, Rule 22, two partners play one ball. They take turns hitting first from the teeing area on each hole and alternate strokes for the rest of it, and a penalty stroke does not change whose turn it is. Each player hits about half the side's shots, which makes it the quickest team format and a good choice for pairs on a tight schedule.

The allowance is 50% of the partners' combined Course Handicaps. In match play, the side with the higher combined figure receives 50% of the difference between the two sides.

Pinehurst, also called Chapman, gives both partners a tee shot on every hole. Each partner drives, each plays the other's ball for the second shot, the side keeps one ball, and the partners alternate from there. SCGA's allowance is 60% of the lower Course Handicap plus 40% of the higher, added before rounding, with .5 rounding up. Neither format posts toward a Handicap Index, since neither partner plays their own ball throughout.

One pair, two formats. In alternate shot match play against a pair whose Course Handicaps add up to 20, this pair receives 5 strokes: 50% of the 10 stroke difference.
FormatPartners' Course HandicapsCalculationSide's handicap
Alternate shot9 and 2150% of 3015
Pinehurst9 and 2160% of 9 plus 40% of 21 = 5.4 + 8.4 = 13.814

Stableford and maximum score cap the bad hole

Stableford, Rule 21.1, compares each hole with a fixed score, which is par unless the committee sets another. In a net competition the fixed score includes your strokes, so a player who receives a stroke on a par 4 is playing to a net par of 5. The player or side with the most points wins.

Once a player can no longer score a point on a hole, Rule 21.1 lets them pick up, and the hole simply scores zero. For a mixed group that matters: with no stroke on a par 4, a 6 and an 8 both score zero, and nobody has to play out the 8.

The recommended allowance is 95%, as for individual stroke play, and the same field size note applies, so a small group can reasonably play off 100%. A player who makes net par on every hole scores 36 points over 18 holes, which makes the totals easy to read: anything above 36 is a good day.

Maximum score, Rule 21.2, is plain stroke play with a cap. The committee sets the cap as two times par, a fixed number or net double bogey, and a player who reaches it picks up and takes the cap. It keeps individual scores while taking the longest holes out of the round.

Stableford points under Rule 21.1b. In net Stableford the fixed score is par plus the strokes the player receives on that hole.
Score on the hole against the fixed scorePoints
More than one over, or no score0
One over1
Fixed score2
One under3
Two under4
Three under5
Four under6

Pace comes down to swings

Indoors, with no walking between shots, the length of a round mostly follows the number of swings. Four players in stroke play make as many swings as their four scores added together. A four-person scramble makes up to four swings for every stroke on the team card, but the team card is lower than any one player's score, because the team always plays its best shot.

As an illustration, four golfers who would shoot 85, 95, 105 and 115 on their own make 400 swings between them in stroke play. If they post 68 as a scramble team, they make at most 272, about a third fewer. Alternate shot halves the count for each pair, and Stableford or a maximum score trims the worst holes.

Best ball sits in between. Every player still plays their own ball, but a player who is out of a hole can pick up once their partner has the better score.

When half the group has no handicap

Office outings and parties often include people with no Handicap Index. The simplest answer is a scramble played gross, with teams balanced by eye: put the strongest players on different teams and spread the beginners around. A gross Stableford with par as the fixed score also works, since a bad hole costs nothing past zero.

For net prizes without handicaps, some outings use a same-day system such as System 36, which works out a handicap from the round being scored. Each hole earns 2 points for par or better, 1 for a bogey and 0 for a double bogey or worse; the handicap is 36 minus the total, and the net score is the gross score minus that handicap. A 90 with 23 points becomes a handicap of 13 and a net 77.

Work through the arithmetic and System 36 nets every bogey and every double bogey to par, so only birdies and holes worse than a double move the net score. A player who makes 9 bogeys and 9 double bogeys on a par 72 shoots 99, scores 9 points, gets a handicap of 27 and nets 72, the same as a scratch golfer who pars every hole. That suits a fun prize better than a competition people care about. Callaway and Peoria are similar same-day systems with their own tables.

If the group plays together often, the better answer is real handicaps. A Handicap Index is issued by an authorized golf association or club, and rounds on rated courses post to it; a simulator round does not.

Matching a format to the group

These are the usual situations, with a format and allowance that fit each. The allowances are the recommended ones; for a small field playing as individuals, 100% is a fair alternative to 95%.

The groupFormatHandicapsWhy it fits
Four coworkers, two of whom rarely playFour-person scramble25%, 20%, 15% and 10%, or noneEvery shot can matter and nobody plays a hole alone
Two pairs of regular golfers, all with an indexBest ball match play90%, lowest plays off zeroEveryone plays their own ball and the round can be posted
A foursome that wants one winnerStableford95%, or 100% for a small fieldA blown hole scores zero instead of adding five strokes
Pairs on a tight scheduleAlternate shot50% of each pair's combined handicapOne ball per pair makes it the quickest team game
Up to 16 players across four baysOne scramble team per bay25%, 20%, 15% and 10%Each bay scores itself, and team net scores rank the field
A mixed group with no handicapsGross scramble, or Stableford against parNoneNo index needed, and a bad hole cannot sink anyone

Playing a group format at Framegolf

Framegolf, on the Culver City border, has four simulator bays for up to four players each, so 16 golfers can play at once with one group per bay. A four-person scramble team fits one bay, two best-ball sides of two share one, and an individual Stableford foursome plays in one bay and compares cards with the other bays afterward.

Anyone can book a bay online, $40/hour off-peak and $60/hour at peak including one golfer, plus $10 per booking for each additional adult; the booking page shows open times and the full price before you pay.

At the published public rates, four golfers sharing a bay for two off-peak hours, the longest public booking, pay $110 in all, $27.50 each; at peak the same booking is $150, or $37.50 each. Peak hours are Mon-Thu 5-10pm, Fri 3-10pm, and Sat-Sun 8am-8pm. The booking holder must attend, and every player must register and complete the required waiver before playing.

For a whole-venue event, Framegolf's private events are buyouts arranged by inquiry, with pricing confirmed in a written agreement. Events are alcohol-free, and every guest registers and signs the waiver online before playing. Members can also play a league season, with their own league entry included in a personal membership.

If you are planning an outing and want to try a format first, the club tour comes with your first hour of golf free, in one bay, for you and up to three friends.

Agree on the terms before the first tee

Appendix C asks the committee to state the allowance in the terms of the competition, and an outing needs the same decisions written down before play: the format and allowance, which tees everyone plays and each player's Course Handicap from them, any maximum score per hole, and for a scramble, the minimum drives per player.

On a simulator, add the software settings. A gimme circle or auto-putt changes scores, so every bay in the event should play the same tees with the same putting setting and mulligan rule. Decide ties in advance too, for example by the better score over the last nine, then the last six, three and final hole; any method works if it is announced first.

Then publish the numbers. A one-line sheet with each team's Course Handicaps, the percentages and the rounded team handicap settles the argument before it starts, and lets everyone check the arithmetic the same way.

Sources and further reading

We use primary sources wherever possible. Product claims remain attributed to the company that made them.

Now open

Book, practice, and improve.

Book a bay by the hour, or become a member and get golf included every month.